T06 · System Persistence
- Location
SKILL.md:274- Finding
Persistent Scheduled Transmission of Sensitive Financial Reports
- Content
View full analysis
- Remediation
View remediation
Security audit
Security checks for vulnerabilities and agentic risk
The skill mostly performs local financial CSV analysis, but it also documents recurring Feishu report delivery in a way that conflicts with its offline/no-network privacy claims.
Review this skill before installing. Its local CSV analysis is straightforward, but do not enable or copy the Feishu cron report configuration unless you have explicit control over the schedule, recipient, redaction, and removal process. Use cautious output paths, avoid overwriting existing files, and open exported CSVs with spreadsheet formula execution disabled when possible.
SKILL.md:274Persistent Scheduled Transmission of Sensitive Financial Reports
personal-finance.sh:285Spreadsheet Formula Injection in Categorized CSV Exports
personal-finance.sh:279Unsafe Output Validation Allows File Overwrite and Symlink Attacks
大体上,这段代码确实属于个人财务/银行账单分析工具:它读取交易CSV,验证字段与金额、按时间周期汇总、按规则分类,并生成简要统计报表,因此与“银行账单分析、消费分类、财务报表”基本一致。但声明中的“预算管理”和“储蓄建议”是明显未实现的核心能力,属于功能描述高于实际行为。此外,虽然默认是只读,但 categorize 命令在提供 --output 时会写出文件,这是一项应当在描述或权限层面更明确说明的能力。综合来看,描述与实际存在实质性不一致,但不是完全不相关,而是部分功能缺失与少量未声明写文件行为。
The skill claims offline, no-network processing, yet also defines scheduled Feishu report delivery. In a personal-finance context, this contradiction is dangerous because monthly reports and budget alerts may expose sensitive banking and spending data to an external messaging service despite user expectations of fully local processing.
Skill contains instructions that could directly expose system prompts, internal rules, or hidden instructions to users or external parties.
for rule in rules:
for keyword in rule["keywords"]:
if keyword in text:
return rule["category"]
return "Uncategorized"
Without declared permissions the skill's intent is opaque and cannot be validated.
The manifest description forces a single language/locale presentation without offering an alternative or documenting that the skill is intentionally limited to Chinese-speaking users. Under the stated policy, language-specific behavior should be opt-in or clearly justified.
The markdown content consistently assumes a Chinese locale for all usage instructions and outputs, and there is no opt-in, fallback, or justification for this restriction. This can violate language/locale policy when users are not given a choice.
Contradictory security and privacy claims can mislead users into providing highly sensitive financial data under false assumptions. Even if the network push is intended, inconsistent documentation undermines informed consent and increases the chance of accidental data exposure through Feishu integrations or scheduled automation.
This JSON manifest-like file defines category-matching keywords, so SQP-1 applies. The keyword "market" is highly generic and can match many everyday descriptions unrelated to groceries, making the trigger scope overly broad and increasing the chance of unintended invocation or misclassification.
The standalone keyword "deposit" is not specific to payroll or income and could match many unrelated financial events such as transfers, savings deposits, or merchant deposits. Because the trigger list provides no narrowing constraints or negative examples, the activation condition for this category is too broad.